Crataegus submollis and Crataegus mollis are very closely related, differing in a number of characteristics, including stamen number, degree of thorniness and stature. In particular, Crataegus mollis has a more westerly range. A number of very good fruiting forms previously recognized as distinct (particularly Crataegus arnoldiana; Crataegus champlainensis ; and perhaps also Crataegus canadensis) are now treated as synonyms of Crataegus submollis - though some treatments view Crataegus arnoldiana as a synonym of Crataegus mollis, or as a distinct hybrid species, Crataegus × anomala[, , ]].
The taxonomy of Crataegus species has historically been very confused, with over 1,200 different species recognized by some authors in the past. This number has been gradually and very significantly reduced, especially since the publication of several regional studies carried out since the late 1980’s, and current thinking is that the final number could be below 150 distinct species[]. Many of the genera that were included in this database prior to 2017 will now be treated as synonyms or subspecies, and it is likely that a number of other currently accepted species will also receive that fate once a complete revision of the genus (underway in 2015) has been published.

Common Name: Red Haw

General Information

Crataegus mollis is a thorny, deciduous shrub or a tree with a wide-spreading head of branches; it can grow 4 - 10 metres tall[, ].
The plant is harvested from the wild for local use as a food. It is grown as an ornamental in gardens, where it can be used to make a thorny hedge.

Known Hazards

None known

Botanical References

, ,

Range

Eastern and Central N. America - North Dakota to Ontario and Michigan, south to Texas and Alabama

Habitat

Open woods, usually in alluvial or fertile soils[]. Frequently found in limestone soils[].

Properties

Edibility Rating
Medicinal Rating
Other Uses Rating
Habit	Deciduous Tree
Height	9.00 m
Growth Rate	Medium
Pollinators	Midges
Cultivation Status	Cultivated, Ornamental, Wild

Cultivation Details

Crataegus mollis is a very hardy plant, tolerating temperatures down to at least -18°c[].
Crataegus species are generally very easily cultivated plants, growing best in full sun to medium shade and preferring a well-drained but moisture retentive loamy soil, though they are not usually fussy[, ]. This species grows well on a chalk soil and also in heavy clay soils[]. Once established, many species can tolerate a range of difficult conditions including drought; excessively moist soils; exposed, windy, maritime conditions; and atmospheric pollution[]. Notes on the plants habitat above may give more ideas on this[].
Trees growing in a sunny position generally produce more and better quality fruit than trees growing in the shade[].
The tree is occasionally cultivated on a garden basis, mainly within its native range, for its edible fruit[]. A very ornamental plant[], the branches of some forms are almost thornless[].
A rather variable species, it has been separated into several different species by some botanists[].
This species is much confused with Crataegus chrysocarpa[] and with Crataegus coccinea[].
Crataegus species often hybridize freely with other members of the genus[, ]. This statement is not fully accurate; at least in the wild most Crataegus species usually breed true and only occasionally hybridize - in addition, any hybrids are usually putative[].
Many Crataegus species are very variable with regard to fruit size and quality. Seedlings, even if obtained from a good fruiting form, can often be disappointing - though they can also be an improvement on the original form. The most reliable way of obtaining a good fruiting form is by grafting from a known good tree, or obtaining a named cultivar from a reliable source[].
Seedling trees take from 5 - 8 years before they start bearing fruit, though grafted trees will often flower heavily in their third year[].
Seedlings should not be left in a seedbed for more than 2 years without being transplanted[].
The flowers have a foetid smell somewhat like decaying fish. This attracts midges which are the main means of fertilization. When freshly open, the flowers have more pleasant scent with balsamic undertones[].


Crataegus arnoldiana is a tree with an excellent potential as a fruit crop in Britain. The fruit is of very good quality and is freely borne, whilst the tree is of very easy cultivation and rarely troubled by pests or diseases[]. A tree at the Hillier Arboretum in September 1993 was about 3 metres tall and 1.5 metres wide. The growth looked somewhat weak and the tree was leaning due to wind rock but it was carrying a heavy crop of fruit[].

Edible Uses

Fruit - raw or cooked[, , , , ]. Sub-acid, dry and mealy[, ]. The fruit is also used for making jellies and preserves[, , ]. Fairly large, it is about 20 - 25mm in diameter[], with a thick flesh[]. There are up to five fairly large seeds in the centre of the fruit, these often stick together and so the effect is of eating a cherry-like fruit with a single seed[].
The bright red (sometimes orange-red or deep red, rarely yellow), suborbicular fruit is 8 - 14mm in diameter[]. The fruit is up to 25mm in diameter[].

A tea-like beverage can be made from the twigs[].

Medicinal

Although no specific mention has been seen for this species, the fruits and flowers of many hawthorns are well-known in herbal folk medicine as a heart tonic and modern research has borne out this use. The fruits and flowers have a hypotensive effect as well as acting as a direct and mild heart tonic[]. They are especially indicated in the treatment of weak heart combined with high blood pressure[]. Prolonged use is necessary for it to be efficacious[]. It is normally used either as a tea or a tincture[].

Agroforestry Uses:

The plant is tolerant of being trimmed and will even resprout if cut back into very old wood. It can be used as a hedge[].

Other Uses

The wood of Crataegus species is generally of good quality, though it is often of too small a size to be of much value. It usually has a red-brown heartwood with a thick band of lighter-coloured, usually pale sapwood. The wood is heavy, extremely hard, tough and close-grained. Where wood of suficient diameter is found it is often greatly prized for use in turnery, and has traditionally been used for purposes such as making tool handles, mallets and other small items[, ].

Propagation

Seed - this is best sown as soon as it is ripe in the autumn in a cold frame, some of the seed will germinate in the spring, though most will probably take another year. Stored seed can be very slow and erratic to germinate, it should be warm stratified for 3 months at 15°c and then cold stratified for another 3 months at 4°c[]. It may still take another 18 months to germinate[]. Scarifying the seed before stratifying it might reduce this time[]. Fermenting the seed for a few days in its own pulp may also speed up the germination process[]. Another possibility is to harvest the seed 'green' (as soon as the embryo has fully developed but before the seedcoat hardens) and sow it immediately in a cold frame. If timed well, it can germinate in the spring[]. If you are only growing small quantities of plants, it is best to pot up the seedlings as soon as they are large enough to handle and grow them on in individual pots for their first year, planting them out in late spring into nursery beds or their final positions. When growing larger quantities, it might be best to sow them directly outdoors in a seedbed, but with protection from mice and other seed-eating creatures. Grow them on in the seedbed until large enough to plant out, but undercut the roots if they are to be left undisturbed for more than two years.